Key takeaway
- Sex-positive feminism sees sexuality as a field of freedom for women to claim, not a danger they need to be protected from by bans.
- It was born in the United States in the early 1980s, in opposition to feminists who wanted to push back pornography through the law.
- It defends pleasure, the equal dignity of all consensual sexualities, the rejection of censorship and the rights of sex workers.
- Feminist porn is its heir: it doesn’t ask for less porn, but for porn made differently.
Is sex the enemy of women, or territory to take back? In the early 1980s, American feminists made their call: territory to take back. So what is sex-positive feminism, exactly? Not a cult of performance, nor a hymn to the adult industry: a current that turns women’s desire into a political question, just like their pay or their right to vote. Here are its ideas, its battles and its figures… and what your screens owe it.
What is sex-positive feminism?
Sex-positive feminism is a current that sees sexuality as a field of freedom for women and sexual minorities, as long as it is chosen. It stands against the feminists who consider pornography and prostitution oppressive by nature, and refuses to let the fight against violence go through the censorship of desire.
The name comes from a journalist, Ellen Willis, a columnist at the Village Voice, who recalled in 2005 having defended what would come to be known as “pro-sex feminism,” after one of her articles titled Lust Horizons: Is the Women’s Movement Pro-Sex?. Today, English mostly says sex-positive feminism. Same family, same intuition: sex isn’t the problem, coercion is.
Among the different types of feminism, it is one of the most often caricatured. But careful: pro-sex doesn’t mean you have to love sex, or have a lot of it. The current sets no standard of good sexuality, abstinence and asexuality included. What it refuses is anyone deciding on women’s behalf what is dignified, degrading or “truly feminist” in their bed.
Key takeaway
Sex-positive feminism doesn’t say that all sex is liberating. It says that sexual freedom is part of women’s emancipation, and that censorship doesn’t protect them.
What do pro-sex feminists stand for?
Pro-sex feminists defend the right to pleasure, the equal dignity of all consensual sexualities, the rejection of censorship and the rights of people who make a living from sex. The thread that ties these fights together fits in one word, consent, thought of alongside desire rather than against it.
The simplest way to grasp these positions is to set them next to those of the opposing camp, abolitionist feminism. On every subject, the question isn’t for or against sex, but who decides.
| Subject | Pro-sex position | Abolitionist position |
| Pornography | A genre to transform: film it differently rather than ban it | A subordination of women, to be fought, even through the law |
| Prostitution | Sex work, with rights to win | A form of violence, to be made to disappear |
| BDSM and minority sexualities | Legitimate practices as long as they are consensual | Often read as a reproduction of domination |
| Role of the state | Protect people, not censor images | Penalize clients, open legal action against pornography |
The first fight is pleasure itself. For centuries, women’s sexuality was thought of in terms of reproduction, marriage or men’s desire. The pro-sex current turns the question around: what if a woman’s pleasure mattered for its own sake, with no love story to justify it? Not dirty, not frivolous, not reserved for “easy girls”. Simply hers.
The second targets the hierarchy of sexualities. Lesbians, leather and BDSM practitioners and queer people carried this current from the start, because morality, feminist morality included, filed their desires as suspect. In the spring of 1982, anthropologist Gayle Rubin led a workshop in New York with a crystal-clear title, Concepts for a Radical Politics of Sex. One idea took hold in this current: no consensual practice is in itself more feminist than another.
The third is the rejection of censorship. As Ellen Willis put it, “the claim that ‘pornography is violence against women’ was code for the neo-Victorian idea that men want sex and women endure it.” The fourth, finally, concerns those who make a living from sex: pro-sex feminists speak of sex work and call for rights rather than bans, to get out of precarity rather than push it underground.
Key takeaway
Pleasure, the equal dignity of consensual sexualities, the rejection of censorship, sex workers’ rights: that is the common ground of pro-sex feminists.
Where does sex-positive feminism come from?
Sex-positive feminism was born in the United States in the early 1980s, in a conflict that came to be called the “sex wars.” On the other side stood feminists who wanted pornography recognized as an attack on women’s rights, and pushed back through the law.
The spark flew in New York. On April 24, 1982, Barnard College hosted the conference The Scholar and the Feminist IX: Toward a Politics of Sexuality, coordinated by anthropologist Carole Vance, with Ellen Willis on the planning committee. On the program: desire, butch and fem roles, “politically incorrect” sexualities… Outside Barnard Hall, the group Women Against Pornography handed out leaflets, and under pressure from anti-porn activists, the administration confiscated the conference diary before it even opened. In 1984, Routledge published the anthology Pleasure and Danger, edited by Carole Vance: pleasure and danger in the same title, without sacrificing one to the other.
The other side struck back in the courts. In Minneapolis, Catharine MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin drafted an amendment defining pornography as “the sexually explicit subordination of women, graphically depicted.” The city council passed it on December 30, 1983, by seven votes to six; six days later, the mayor vetoed it. Indianapolis adopted a similar text in 1984, giving anyone who claimed to have been harmed by such images the right to sue their makers and sellers. In 1985, a federal appeals court ruled it contrary to the First Amendment, the one that protects freedom of speech. Among the voices that fought it in court: the Feminist Anti-Censorship Taskforce, feminists against censorship.
Meanwhile, pro-sex feminists practiced what they preached: they made their own images. In 1984, Susie Bright, who had worked at Good Vibrations, a feminist sex store, launched On Our Backs, the first lesbian sex magazine in the United States, with photographer Honey Lee Cottrell, Deborah Sundahl and Nan Kinney. Its proudly claimed tagline: “entertainment for the adventurous lesbian.”
Key takeaway
Sex-positive feminism was born from a clash: faced with anti-porn laws, it chose freedom of speech, and making its own images.
Who champions sex-positive feminism in the US and the UK?
In the English-speaking world, sex-positive feminism is at home: it was born in the United States, and its debates run through the United Kingdom too. It is carried by people who know the subject from the inside: porn, writing, sex work. Yet the law, on both sides of the Atlantic, has rarely followed it.
In the United States, one of its best-known defenses came from a lawyer: in 1995, Nadine Strossen, then president of the American Civil Liberties Union, published Defending Pornography (Scribner), a feminist case against censoring sexual expression. Its bookshelf also holds two French voices. In 2002, actress and director Ovidie published Porno manifesto with Flammarion: a former porn performer picks up the pen, and it’s porn she defends. Four years later, novelist Virginie Despentes wrote King Kong théorie (Grasset, 2006), translated into English as King Kong Theory. Three books, three voices, and the same refusal: letting others speak for them.
The fight also goes through the law. In 1973, Margo St. James founded COYOTE (Call Off Your Old Tired Ethics) in San Francisco, which provided legal and medical services to sex workers; in Britain, the English Collective of Prostitutes started in 1975 and campaigns for decriminalization. The law mostly goes the other way. In the United States, the exchange of sex for money remains illegal for sellers and buyers alike, except in Nevada, where some rural counties allow licensed brothels, and in Maine, which since 2023 has punished only those who buy. In England and Wales, buying and selling sex are not crimes in themselves, but keeping a brothel is. Activists like Maria Riot defend the rights of sex workers against all these bans. The sex wars debate has changed stages: from American campuses to state legislatures and the British Parliament.
Key takeaway
In the US and the UK, the pro-sex current has its authors and its sex workers’ organizations, but the law still bans the sex trade almost everywhere in the US and hems it in with offenses in Britain.
From sex-positive feminism to feminist porn
Feminist porn is the most visible child of sex-positive feminism. Rather than banning images, it makes them differently: with the gaze of women and minorities behind the camera, negotiated scenes and performers who get paid.
The gesture didn’t wait for the word. Candida Royalle, an actress who became a producer at 30, founded her own company, Femme Productions, and according to the New York Times championed an explicit, sensual cinema made for women. In 2006, Chanelle Gallant created the Feminist Porn Awards in Toronto, with the store Good For Her. In 2013, The Feminist Porn Book, edited by Tristan Taormino, Celine Parreñas Shimizu, Constance Penley and Mireille Miller-Young, brought together adult performers and academics around one question: is pornography necessarily anti-feminist?
Today, directors like Erika Lust have turned it into a cinema in its own right. Yet feminist porn doesn’t claim that all porn is liberating: it asks the questions inherited from the sex wars, who’s filming, who’s getting paid and who’s consenting. And that’s where sex-positive feminism stops being a theory and becomes a viewer’s choice.
What criticisms are leveled at sex-positive feminism?
Sex-positive feminism has its opponents, starting with abolitionist feminists. For them, individual choice weighs little against power relations: poverty, racism or violence weigh on the “consent” of those who perform on camera or sell sex.
Their most radical argument comes down to a definition. For Catharine MacKinnon and Andrea Dworkin, pornography is not a representation but a practice: a subordination of women that no freedom of speech can justify. Criticism also comes from inside the pro-sex camp: consent is only worth something if it is free, and a shoot remains a job, with an employer, a wage and a power imbalance. Those shooting conditions are exactly what ethical porn has made its rule.
FAQ about sex-positive feminism
Are pro-sex feminism and sex-positive feminism the same thing?
Yes, they are two names for the same current. English today mostly says sex-positive feminism; pro-sex feminism is the expression Ellen Willis made known with Lust Horizons.
Can you be a pro-sex feminist without watching porn?
Of course. The current defends a freedom, not an obligation: you can never watch porn, live in abstinence or identify as asexual, and still share its ideas. What matters: not imposing your own standard on others.
Is sex-positive feminism in favor of prostitution?
It is in favor of the rights of the people who do it. Pro-sex feminists speak of sex work and call for a framework that protects, while abolitionists want prostitution to disappear, like the Maine law of 2023, which still punishes buyers but no longer those who sell sex.
Which books should you read to discover sex-positive feminism?
In English, Defending Pornography by Nadine Strossen (Scribner, 1995) and King Kong Theory by Virginie Despentes, translated by Stéphanie Benson (Feminist Press, 2010), then by Frank Wynne (Fitzcarraldo Editions, 2020). Add the anthology Pleasure and Danger edited by Carole Vance (1984) and The Feminist Porn Book (2013).